Web of Lies: Art Fraud Online


Click Here

Chatelaine's Antiques and Appraisals Magazine > Market Notes > Feature: Web of Lies: Art Fraud Online

Art Fraud

Stealing Art

Internet Fraud Complaint Center

Click Here

Web of Lies: Art Fraud Online

Knowledgeable collectors aren't easily fooled, but the allure of big bargains make others vulnerable

The real thing: Kokoschka's The Crab, 1939-40
The real thing:
Kokoschka's The Crab, 1939-40

The issue of fake paintings on the Internet came to light on May 9, 2000 with the purported Richard Diebenkorn a painting that apparently wasn't by Diebenkorn at all and the $135,000 bid it attracted on eBay. It was also highlighted by New York Attorney General Gerald Spitzer's investigation and bust of convicted auctioneer and sleight-of-hand artist Jerold Schuster.

But the problem is not one of fakes. It's more about marketing tricks, half-truths, and misrepresentations. The "Diebenkorn" was an abstract painting with the initials R.D. on it. The seller later admitted to fabricating details about the painting's history. In his original description of the painting, he claimed that he'd found it at a garage sale in Berkeley, California, not that far from where Diebenkorn painted his abstract masterpieces, and that he knew nothing about it. To add a personal touch to the listing, he said his wife didn't like it and wouldn't let him keep it in the house. The seller made no mention of the fact that he was a lawyer, that he'd sold on eBay previously, under a different username, or that he'd arranged for friends to enter bids on the painting to make it seem that it was a hot item and in play.

While his dodge was complicated and sophisticated, Schuster relied on other techniques. He listed a painting as being signed by "Coy Rose", leading the bidders to think it might be a work by the California Impressionist Guy Rose.

A poor imitation
A poor imitation:
Schuster tried to pass this art
student work off as a Kokoschka

Schuster once found a painting that was by an art student who signed the work with an indistinct "DK", the "D" rounded enough so that it looked like an "O". He listed it as a work signed "OK" and as the creation of Austrian Expressionist Oskar Kokoschka, whose paintings routinely sell for hundreds of thousands of dollars. The claim made a big difference to the buyer, who was hunting for a discovery. He paid $6,101 for the painting. In each case, it was a simple technique of "reattribution."

A favorite trick of his simply involved taking a painting with some signs of age, adding a forged signature, and then declaring it to be an authentic work by a known artist. Often, the style or subjects of the paintings don't look much like the works of the actual artist. At other times, there's a resemblance because the paintings are copies.

According to Jane Kallir, co-director of the Galerie St. Etienne in New York, "Many, many fakes are actually innocent copies of famous works, probably done by admiring fans. These find their way into the market through yard sales or at flea markets, and attract buyers hoping to find a bargain."

These fakes and indeed the majority of fakes are of very poor quality, says Kallir. "No one with even modest knowledge of the artist's work is likely to be fooled. But making a great flea market find like winning the lottery has become part of the American dream," she says.

The only difference nowadays, says Kallir, is that on the Internet, people spend thousands of dollars on these bogus things, whereas formerly they rarely spent more than a couple hundred.



Introduction to Object ID: Guidelines for Making Records That Describe Art, Antiques, and Antiquities
by Robin Thornes

Old Masters Repainted: A Detailed Investigation into the Authenticity of Paintings Attributed to Wu Zhen (1280-1354)
by Joan Stanley-Baker

The Art Forger's Handbook
by Eric Hebborn

The Commissar Vanishes : The Falsification of Photographs and Art in Stalin's Russia
by David King

The Fake
by Sandor Radnoti

Detecting Forgery: Forensic Investigation of Documents
by Joe Nickell

Getting an Appraisal

What is an Appraisal By Mail?

Our Appraisal Services

Discount subscriptions at MAGAZINES.com


(Great Modern Master Series)

by Oskar Kokoschka

Oskar Kokoschka Memorial Exhibition
by Johann Winkler

Oskar Kokoschka
by Klaus Albrecht Schroder